Average Girl Reads

The Edge of Town

The Edge of Town is set in 1922 and it follows the residents of a small Missouri town. The main family, the Joneses, is pretty much being held together by the eldest daughter Julie. She is a 20-year-old who quit school at 16 to take care of the household for her father and her siblings when her mother died. She has a budding romance with Evan, the son of the local foul-mouthed drunk. There is a subplot involve a man who has been raping young girls in the town for years and getting them pregnant.

I tried hard to stick with this book, but I finally gave up. I've read that there is also a murder in the plot which I didn't get to because having romance and rape in the same book was jarring for me. I don't consider myself a prude, but reading a scene about happy family life on the farm and then having it followed by a character expressing his sexual preference for little kids in rather crude language was a bit much for me. When the book switched back to the sweet scenes, I couldn't enjoy them. Having the mystery of the rapist still hanging out there cast a shadow over the romance for me.

While it is fun for a book to have some surprises, I like to have a feeling for what type of book I'm reading from the start. Although I read a lot of Christian historical romances, I also sprinkle in modern romances, magical realism, literary fiction, memoirs, and lots of other genres. Foul language and difficult subject matter isn't quite as unsettling if I chose to read that kind of book.

Spring for SusannahSpring for Susannah by Catherine Richmond
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Summary, from Goodreads:

When her parents die suddenly, and no suitors call, Susannah resigns herself to the only option available: becoming a mail-order bride. Agreeing to marry her pastor's brother, Jesse, Susannah leaves the only home she's ever known for the untamed frontier of the Dakota Territory.

I really enjoyed this book. It was a cut above many Christian romances I have read, as far as the depth of the main characters. Although there was one major incident that precipitated Susannah's move to the Dakota Territory, the story is really about her overcoming her shyness and two strangers getting to know each other.

The author did a great job of showing the passage of time so the reader can believe how the couple fell in love. In some books the courtship seems to be rushed which makes the happy ending less believable, especially if the plot involves a mail-order bride. I want to feel like the couple have gone through several events, big and small, that draw them together.

This book moved me enough that I was disappointed to find that Catherine Richmond has only written one other stand-alone book. If there ever was a book that I wished was part of a series, it's this one. I wanted to spend more time with the main couple and the other characters in the small community. I definitely want to get my hands on a copy of Richmond's other book, and I hope she writes more soon.

View all my reviews

I just read that poet Rod McKuen died this week. When I was going through my poetry obsession in my teens, Rod McKuen was one of the poets that I read repeatedly. So much poetry was difficult for me to understand; it was just a collection of pretty words. I enjoyed the rhythm but didn't really get the overall meaning. McKuen's work seemed more down-to-earth to me. Running across his obituary today makes me want to revisit his work and poetry in general to see if 30-odd years of life experience will bring me more understanding.

Until I put a halt to adding books to my to-be-read list, I didn't realize how often I ran into information about books. Besides the three daily newsletters that notify me about free e-books, I have reading recommendations staring me in the face on Goodreads, on my library's website, and in my Facebook newsfeed. Then, when I'm watching the Today show or CBS Sunday Morning, there is usually at least one or two authors saying something interesting that makes me want to check out their books. There is temptation everywhere I look!

One of the reasons I set this no-add goal was to get out of my rut and read something on my list that wasn't a prairie romance, and I started that last week. I read Juliet, Naked by Nick Hornby. I've watched a couple of movies based on his novels, so I knew his books were exactly happy. Still, that book took a little longer for me to finish because I knew after 10 pages that there wasn't going to be a happy ending. Hornby is great with words and there were several passages that made me smile, but overall it was a book where the characters didn't really seem any better off by the end of the book. That's a little sad for me, but I'm glad that I pushed myself to read something different. I'm treating myself to another prairie romance before I tackle another tough book :-).

The Half-Stitched Amish Quilting ClubThe Half-Stitched Amish Quilting Club by Wanda E. Brunstetter
My rating: 1 of 5 stars

Summary from Goodreads:

Join the club of unlikely quilters who show up for Amish widow Emma Yoder’s quilting classes. A troubled young woman, a struggling couple, a widower, a rough and tough biker, and a preacher’s wife make up the mismatched lot. But as their problems begin to bind them together like the scraps of fabric stitched together in a quilt, they learn to open up and lend a helping hand. Is this what God had in mind to heal hurting hearts and create beauty from fragments?

I wanted to like this book. It is a familiar trope: the misfit group of people who are forced together into a situation and build friendships despite their differences. It is a story setup that I normally enjoy, but in this book it didn't gel. The dialogue didn't feel natural, and the friendships between the characters weren't fleshed out enough. The entire book seemed like a sketch of the book that someone wanted to write instead of the final draft.

I have three other Wanda E. Brunstetter books on my Goodreads list. I had heard that she is one of the leading authors in the Amish fiction genre, but after this I'm not sure if I want to try another of her books.  

View all my reviews

Deeply DevotedDeeply Devoted by Maggie Brendan
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

Summary from Goodreads:

When Catharine Olsen leaves Holland for America as a mail-order bride, she brings along some extra baggage: two sisters, her mother's set of Blue Willow china, and a tragic past. When she arrives in Cheyenne, Wyoming, she promptly marries Peter Andersen and dreams of starting life over in this rugged land. Peter is kind and patient with Catharine and accommodating to her sisters. His mother, however, is not. When she begins a campaign to sabotage Peter's marriage, Catharine is distraught, worried that her secret past will be discovered. Will her life end up as nothing but broken pieces? Or will these trials make her stronger?

This book ticked all my boxes. It is a prairie romance with a mail-order bride who is a new arrival from Europe, so there is also a bit of a culture clash. There were real secrets and issues in this book, unlike some books where the whole central conflict could have been resolved with one five-minute conversation. It is spread over a long period time so that the reader can see Peter and Catharine's love grow. The subplot with Clara, Peter's mother, was fleshed out and showed her as a woman with needs and reasons for her bad behavior. All of these aspects added up to a satisfying novel for me.

The one little quirk that bothered me in this novel was the way Catharine's sister Greta talked. I'm not an expert in 19th-century speech patterns or anything, but Greta sounded more modern than the other characters. She would utter phrases like, "Cut it out, Cath!", which sounds more like something one of my daughters would say, not a 19th-century teenager whose first language is not English. 

This is the first book in a three-book series. It doesn't end in a cliffhanger so you can stop with this book, but the author did create plot points that give you a reason to pick up the other books. If you enjoy spending time with the characters in this book, then this is good news. 

View all my reviews

Older Posts